Another Zimmer Hip Replacement Failure

Another consumer has had to undergo revision surgery due to the failure of his Zimmer Durom Hip Cup implant. The surgery was performed to correct a Zimmer hip replacement that failed to perform as promised by the manufacturer Zimmer Inc. Plano resident Victor Barakat underwent revision surgery in April 2009, after enduring pain due to the loose hip implant for almost three years.

According to the plaintiff the Zimmer hip replacement failed to incur a permanent fixation to the bone through in-growth as the manufacturer advertised. Barakat filed suit in the Marshall Division of the Eastern District of Texas, on March 10, against both Zimmer Inc. and Zimmer Holdings. The causes of action being filed against the named manufacturers include failure to warn, design defect, marketing defect, manufacturing defect, negligence, negligent misrepresentation, breach of implied warranty.

Hip Implant Patient Asks For Punitive Damages

Barakat is also asking to be awarded punitive damages, he is arguing that the defendants were aware of the “extreme degree of risk caused by the defects in the Durom Cup, but preceded with conscious indifference to the rights, safety, and welfare of others, namely Plaintiff.” Barakat’s argument says the hip implant does not meet the specifications and guidelines of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

He claims the defendants used “unconscionable commercial business practices” and concealed material facts about the hip implant. In July 2008, Zimmer Holdings announced a suspension of sales of the Durom cup. The company said it would be training doctors in best practices for the hip implant. Zimmer Holdings admitted that a low percentage of their 13,000 patients with hip implants of the Durom Cup would need replacement surgery.

Some doctors, familiar with the device, believed at the time, the revision surgeries would total many more than Zimmer expected. Had the Durom cup patients lived in a country such as Australia, Britain, or Norway, where artificial joints are tracked by national databases, fewer patients would have suffered. The United States lacks a joint registry for tracking how patients fare with artificial hips and knees.

Zimmer Hip Replacement Study Failure

The fact that the U.S. does not have a joint registry effectively doubles the number of patients that will require a replacement procedure. A recent study of 181 patients (207 hips) who had a Zimmer Durom Metasul acetabular component ( Zimmer Durom cup) with large-diameter articulation implanted between May 2006 and November 2007 showed an abnormally high rate of revision surgery required.

Zimmer Biomet Reverse Shoulder Replacement

With a minimum follow up of 1 year (mean, 1.6 years; range, 1-2 years) the study showed that 29 patients (30 hips) of the 181 (207 hips) required revision surgery or 15%. Of the 30 Zimmer hip replacements that required revision surgery, 21 were replaced due to loosening of the cup, 72%.

Twenty-eight of the 151 unrevised patients had radiographic impending failure. That would eventually push the failure rate to close to 30 per cent. The report concluded about the success of the Durom cup, “The revision rate and quality of clinical results were unacceptable as compared with our historical controls. We do not recommend use of the Durom  implant.” For more information on the Zimmer Durom cup click here Zimmer hip replacement.

If you or a loved one has had a Zimmer Durom cup implanted and you are suffering pain and discomfort, contact us at The Law Offices of Nadrich & Cohen, we can help you.

Do I Have A Case?

We offer free consultation. No office visit required, we will get back to you within 24 hours.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


What can we do for you?

  • Answer your legal question.
  • Provide a Free Case Evaluation.
  • Schedule an appointment.


Choose Us?

  • Available 24/7
  • Trusted Since 1990
  • Local to You
  • Recovered $350,000,000
  • 5 Star Reviews
  • Free Case Evaluation
  • VIP Service
  • No Win, No Fee

Latest Law Post

May 8, 2019

Best Bike Cities 2019

The California cities of Santa Barbara, Santa Monica, San Diego, Ventura, Lompoc, Goleta, Santa Maria, Long Beach and Carpinteria were all in the top 50 best overall cities for bicycling compiled by People For Bikes in May 2019. Santa Barbara was ranked the highest of all California cities, in 12th place.

May 1, 2019

Understanding Car Insurance Costs

Before buying a new car, you may want to consider all costs of owning a vehicle not just your monthly car payment. One of the biggest expenses associated with owning or leasing a car, besides the monthly car payment, is insurance. In some cases, insurance can cost as much or even more than your car payment.


We are Personal Injury Lawyers representing accident victims throughout California.
For 30 years, the law firm of Nadrich & Cohen, LLP has helped injury victims
obtain the compensation they deserve.