FDA Drops the Ball, Allows Infected Duodenoscopes to be Used

Infected DuodenoscopesThe role of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is to keep dangerous drugs and products away from consumers. So the question on the minds of many people is why the FDA allowed hospitals and other medical facilities to continue using tainted duodenoscopes, even after it was known that these medical instruments had caused serious infections that led to fatalities, in some instances.

The reason? The FDA misplaced an important report. This report detailed a deadly superbug outbreak that occurred in 2012 at a Pennsylvania hospital. It was determined that the outbreak was caused by tainted duodenoscopes, due to their defective design which made it difficult to clean and disinfect between uses. Because the devices were not properly sterilized, bacteria were able to spread from patient to patient. As a result of losing the report, the FDA was unable to timely inform medical providers of the infection risk associated with the design of certain duodenoscopes. Without this important information, doctors continued to use the medical devices for three more years, until the FDA finally notified medical providers through a safety alert.

sixteen hospitals with infected duodenoscope outbreaksThe FDA counts on manufacturers and hospitals to properly report any issues with medical devices. However, most fail to do so because they’re afraid of being sued by injured consumers. Often, medical device companies will go to great lengths to cover up patient illnesses or injuries. Of the sixteen hospitals with infected duodenoscope outbreaks, not one properly submitted an adverse event report. Some hospitals do send reports to the manufacturer, but some manufacturers subsequently edit the report and falsify information, prior to forwarding the report to the FDA.

Further complicating reporting of adverse events is the FDA’s outdated database. The FDA has even admitted that its current system for monitoring the safety of medical devices is flawed. The agency is working to create a new reporting system, but some of the necessary components are too costly. It is anticipated that upgrading to a new and accessible database could take another ten years.

Do I Have A Case?

We offer free consultation. No office visit required, we will get back to you within 24 hours.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


What can we do for you?

  • Answer your legal question.
  • Provide a Free Case Evaluation.
  • Schedule an appointment.


Choose Us?

  • Available 24/7
  • Trusted Since 1990
  • Local to You
  • Recovered $350,000,000
  • 5 Star Reviews
  • Free Case Evaluation
  • VIP Service
  • No Win, No Fee

Latest Law Post

May 8, 2019

Best Bike Cities 2019

The California cities of Santa Barbara, Santa Monica, San Diego, Ventura, Lompoc, Goleta, Santa Maria, Long Beach and Carpinteria were all in the top 50 best overall cities for bicycling compiled by People For Bikes in May 2019. Santa Barbara was ranked the highest of all California cities, in 12th place.

May 1, 2019

Understanding Car Insurance Costs

Before buying a new car, you may want to consider all costs of owning a vehicle not just your monthly car payment. One of the biggest expenses associated with owning or leasing a car, besides the monthly car payment, is insurance. In some cases, insurance can cost as much or even more than your car payment.


We are Personal Injury Lawyers representing accident victims throughout California.
For 30 years, the law firm of Nadrich & Cohen, LLP has helped injury victims
obtain the compensation they deserve.